The Upside of Too Many Men

Men on motorcycles, center man in white shirt is smoking a cigarette.

Taiwan’s (China) oversupply of men in the 1960s contributed to economic growth. Source: © 2011 C. Stowers/Panos

What happens when there are too many men for a given population of women? The men become entrepreneurs, work harder and longer, and save more. That’s what two researchers revealed in a new IFPRI discussion paper, The Economic Consequences of Excess Men, on the economic impact of too many marriage-eligible men in 1960s Taiwan.

A Skewed Sex Ratio

In the late 1940s, defeat by the Chinese Communist Party drove 1 million Chinese Nationalist Party members—most of whom were young, unmarried men—to Taiwan, China. Their arrival skewed the sex ratio in the country of 6 million; by 1950, in the 20–24 age bracket, there were 150 men for every 100 women.

But these bachelors didn’t throw the country’s marriage dynamics off track—at least not immediately. The head of the Chinese Nationalist Party, Chiang Kai-shek, imposed a marriage ban so that his men would be ready to attack in the event of war with the Communists. He didn’t lift the ban until 1959. That’s when competition for mates kicked in.

Get Rich Quick

Examining datasets from the time period (and borrowing a page from Darwin), Simon Chang of China’s Central University of Finance and Economics and Xiaobo Zhang of IFPRI discovered the economic consequences of this imbalanced sex ratio. They found that men in 1960s Taiwan, China engaged in economic behavior to make themselves more attractive to potential mates. In short, they tried to get wealthy—fast.

More specifically, to attract the too-small pool of women, these unattached men became enthusiastic entrepreneurs—the fastest way to accumulate wealth. If they didn’t start new businesses, they worked longer hours to earn more and move up the career ladder.

According to Chang and Zhang, this uptick in entrepreneurship and hard work, sparked by competition for mates, ultimately contributed to Taiwan’s (China) 20th-century economic miracle.

Zhang points out, however, that the goal of the study isn’t to promote government policies to alter a country’s sex ratios.

“The aim is to show that some aspects of human economic behavior might have a biological root,” he says, “and that fusing a biological perspective with economic analysis can shed new insight on human economic behaviors and outcomes.”

For more information on a related topic:

The effect of “too many men” on housing prices in China

In This Issue

Building Bigger Dreams

Can we improve people’s well-being by raising their aspirations?

Into the Spotlight

The grain teff has been consumed as a staple in Ethiopia for centuries but is little known outside the country. Now, researchers are training their attention on this understudied crop.

Untangling the Asian Enigma

Although South Asia has the highest concentration of undernutrition in the world, in the past two decades Bangladesh and Nepal have both achieved striking improvements in the nutrition of their citizens. How did they do it?

Does Money Talk?

FEATURE: Millions of poor people around the world are enrolled in safety net programs that hand out cash or food. What’s the best way to design these transfer programs?